Understanding the Pros and Cons of Cold Emailing in Freight Brokerage – Freight 360

Understanding the Pros and Cons of Cold Emailing in Freight Brokerage – Freight 360

Freight 360 By Freight 360

As a freight broker, you recognize the significance of prospecting new shippers and expanding your client base. One method to reach potential shippers is through cold emailing. Cold emails are unsolicited messages sent to prospects who have not previously expressed interest in your services. The objective of cold emails is to grab their attention, introduce your services, and offer solutions to their shipping needs. But how effective are cold emails for freight brokers? What are the merits and drawbacks of this prospecting method? In this article, we will delve into the pros and cons of freight broker cold emails and provide insights on how to craft them.

Cold Email

Pros of Freight Broker Cold Emails

  • Broad Reach: They enable you to connect with a substantial number of prospects in a brief period. Using email marketing tools or software, you can automate the process and send personalized messages to hundreds or even thousands of shippers simultaneously.
  • Highlighting Value Proposition: They allow you to emphasize your unique selling points, differentiating you from competitors. You can showcase your expertise, experience, network, rates, and customer service. Including testimonials, case studies, or success stories can further bolster trust and credibility.
  • Starting Conversations: Emails can be a starting point for dialogues with prospects. With compelling subject lines and engaging content, you can entice recipients to open, read, and respond without needing a phone call. Follow-up calls can then guide them through the sales funnel towards becoming customers.

Cons of Freight Broker Cold Emails

  • Perception as Spam: Cold emails can feel intrusive and often get ignored or deleted. Many shippers receive an overwhelming number of emails daily and may not have the time or interest in reading yours. Some may even mark your message as spam or block your address if deemed irrelevant.
  • Challenges in Writing: Crafting effective cold emails requires thorough research, segmentation, engaging content, persuasive wording, and continuous optimization. You must also test variations and monitor the outcomes to determine the most effective approach.
  • Comparison to Phone Calls: Generally, phone calls may be a more effective prospecting method than emails. However, a balanced combination of both can be an effective strategy for communicating information to a prospect before speaking to them directly.

Tips for Writing Freight Broker Cold Emails

If you choose to integrate cold emails into your prospecting strategy, here are some tips for effective communication:

  • Do Your Homework: Research prospects’ needs and tailor your email to demonstrate an understanding of their specific requirements. Personalization enhances your credibility and relevance.
  • Write a Catchy Subject Line: Craft a concise, clear, and intriguing subject line that conveys a benefit. For instance, “Flatbeds available in Atlanta for backhaul to Chicago” might be more appealing than “How ABC Logistics Can Help You.”
  • Keep it Short and Simple: Your email should be concise and reader-friendly. Avoid jargon or overly complex language. Utilize bullet points and headings to enhance readability. Focus on one main idea per email, and don’t overload the reader with information.
  • Provide Evidence and Social Proof: Support your claims with evidence or testimonials from previous clients. For example, share how you have consistently provided reliable dry van capacity for a local shipper.
  • Include a Clear Call to Action: Provide a well-defined next step, such as notifying the prospect of an upcoming phone call or requesting to be added to their daily load list.

Cold emailing can be an influential tool for growing your business, although it may never replace the human connection achieved through a phone call. Many brokers utilize this technique, but finding a balance between phone calls and emails is likely to yield the best results.

Follow us in Youtube for more insights about the freight broker industry!

About the Author


To read more about Freight 360, check out full bio here.